Are the One Year MBA Courses Worth it?

 

A simple one word answer to this question will be – “YES.” Now, let’s elaborate on this “Yes”.

To begin with, one-year MBA program need not mean that it is not a regular MBA. It is a myth that all “regular” MBA programs are 2 year MBA programs.

Traditional one-year MBA programs: A lot of B schools offer only one year MBA programs. Almost all the European MBA programs are one year programs. These programs are designed for people with work-experience, and hence, are compact programs. Often, they do not have the mandatory industry internship. Since these programs have traditionally been one year programs, the curriculum is designed accordingly. As a result, students gain complete benefit out of the program including placement opportunities. Some of the top European B schools which offer only one-year MBA programs areOxford, Cambidge, IE, IESE, INSEAD, etc.

Pros: The biggest positive of these one year programs is the opportunity cost. Students stay away from the job market for only one year and hence, lose only one year’s salary. Within one year, they are again in the job market with an enhanced Resume and skill sets. An indication of the worthiness of these one year MBA programs is the average starting salary of an MBA graduate of these B schools. For instance, in 2010, the mean salary of the graduating MBA class of INSEAD was € 87,400.

Cons: The absence of the mandatory industry internship makes it comparatively difficult for international students to land a job. This tends to be an even bigger problem during periods of economic slowdown. Moreover, from day one, a student has to be on the lookout for job opportunities, which can create a lot of pressure to international students.

US and Canadian one-year MBA programs: InUSA andCanada, the traditional MBA program is for 2 years and has a mandatory industry internship. However, some colleges such asQueens, Richard Ivy, Kellogg, Cornell, etc. offer one – yr MBA programs for people with more work experience. These one-year programs have a compact curriculum and are more general management focused as compared to the 2 year MBA programs. Also, these one year programs do not have the internship program.

Pros: Like the European one year MBA programs, the biggest positive of the one year programs offered by theUS and Canadian B schools is the opportunity cost. Students stay away from the job market for only one year and hence, lose only one year’s salary. Within one year, they are again in the job market with an enhanced Resume and skillsets. As compared to students who do the 2 year MBA program, the students who do the one year programs spend one year’s worth of cost of living less and earn one year’s worth of salary more. Very fewUS and Canadian B schools offer one year MBAs and they smaller class sizes. As a result, placements are usually not difficult.

Cons: The biggest disadvantage of the one year programs offered by theUS and Canadian B schools is that this is usually not the traditional MBA program of that school. As a result, graduates of the one year MBA program tend to get lesser starting salaries than the graduates of the 2 year MBA program of that B school. In fact, very often, B schools clearly specify that the one year program is for people who plan to go back to their companies or family businesses. A case in point is the one year MBA programs offered byColumbiaBusinessSchool.

Moreover, the absence of the mandatory industry internship makes it comparatively difficult for international students to land a job during periods of economic slowdown. In addition to this, students are not able to earn as they would have done if there was a paid internship.

Also, from day one, a student has to be on the lookout for job opportunities, which can create a lot of pressure to international students.

Indian one-year MBA programs: In India,IndianSchool of Business,Hyderabad and Great Lakes, Chennai offer the only truly one yr MBA programs inIndia. These B schools offer only one year MBA programs and are designed for people with work experience. These MBA programs are industry focused and have great placements. For instance, graduates of ISB usually get a 200% hike in their pre-MBA salary.

Since the past few years, a few of the Indian Institutes of Management, in addition to their standard 2 year MBA programs, have started offering full time one year MBA programs for people who have work experience of 5-7 years.  These MBA programs are general management focused and do not include any internship. The Indian Institutes of Management which offer one year MBA programs are IIM Ahmedabad, IIM Bangalore, IIM Calcutta, IIM Indore and IIM Lucknow-Noida. In the one year programs of the IIMs, majority of the class comprises of sponsored candidates who have been sent on a study sabbatical by their organizations. The biggest disadvantage of the one year programs offered by the IIMs is that this is not their traditional MBA program. As a result, they always end up playing second fiddle to the 2 year MBA program.

In conclusion, if a one year MBA happens to be the traditional or flag ship MBA program of a B school, then it is as good as any 2 year MBA program, and is definitely worth the investment. However, if a B school offers a one year MBA program, in addition to a 2 year MBA program, then go through the placement data carefully before applying.

3 people like this post.

You may also like...

  • rakesh

    Whoever wrote this article must have been paid by ISB.First of all ISB is a private school
    which has only motive i.e. to make profit and has notorious history of deceiving innocent
    people. Why ISB is not disclosing placement statistics as per audited norms of CRISIL as
    it is done by IIM Ahmedabad?

    ISB admits candidates who actually do not qualify for 1 year MBA. Most of students joining
    ISB one program have just 3-4 year of work experience and they are the students who either
    could not clear CAT exams or does not meet admission requirements of IIM ‘s one year MBA.
    ISB is never preferred by experienced executives just for only reason that it is below their dignity
    to share class room with inexperienced candidates.

    Every year ISB struggles to place candidates and even when candidates are hired from ISB , they
    are given entry level job unlike IIM Ahmedabad PGPX candidates who are always recruited for very
    senior position. Most of the IIM PGPX candidates are hired for at least General Manager role and
    many are given VP,CEO,Country head position. Furthermore, there is huge difference in salary
    offered to IIM PGPX and ISB PGP students. The average salary offered at IIM Ahmedabad isaround
    30 lakhs and the salary as reported by ISB is around 17 lakhs. On top of that one can never know
    what the actual salary figure at ISB is because it does not release audited report.

    In terms of ranking, IIM Ahemdabad PGPX is always well ahead of ISB in all ranking list .ISB has now
    started new propaganda to fool people by bringing its part time program PGPMAX instead of its regular
    PGP program in ranking list to inflate salary.

    Also there is no match of education quality between IIM PGPX and ISB.IIM Ahmedabad is renowned
    for case based pedagogy and it offers the same curriculum of its 2 year PGP program in 1 year
    PGPX program.

     
Read previous post:
Networking

 “Why do you want to pursue an MBA?” If you pose this question to any MBA aspirant, you will get...

Close